ProEdge Life Coaching

The Follow Through: Identity Lag and Why You Sabotage Progress

When Your Growth Outpaces Your Identity

A few years ago, I watched a friend train for her first half-marathon. At first, she ran slowly, almost sheepishly, and laughed at herself for being “not a real runner.” But after weeks of early mornings and sore muscles, something curious happened: her body adapted faster than her self-image. She could run ten miles, but still described herself as “out of shape.”

That gap between her actions and her identity wasn’t just awkward — it was painful. She skipped runs, sabotaged her own nutrition, and nearly quit, all because the story in her head hadn’t caught up with her new reality.

I’ve felt that, too. For me, it showed up when I became more consistent in my work routines. On the outside, I was meeting deadlines and showing up prepared. On the inside, though, I still carried the self-concept of someone who procrastinates. It was as though the “old me” was tugging on my sleeve, whispering, This isn’t really you. Don’t get too comfortable.

Psychologists call this cognitive dissonance — the stress of holding conflicting beliefs about ourselves (Festinger, 1957). James Clear, in Atomic Habits, writes that “true behavior change is identity change.” When our behavior upgrades but our identity lags, the friction often shows up as self-sabotage.

Here’s the paradox: sometimes growth feels destabilizing, not because we’re failing, but because we’re succeeding faster than our identity can integrate. The body learns one pace. The identity lags behind. And that lag creates sabotage — little slips, avoidance, or self-doubt that bring us back to the familiar.

Progress often isn’t about discipline or motivation. It’s about letting yourself believe the new story you’re already living.

A Small Experiment

This week, instead of trying to “push harder,” try this: at the end of each day, write down one thing you did that the “old you” would have thought unlikely or even impossible. It doesn’t have to be dramatic — maybe it’s answering an email right away, finishing a workout, or speaking up in a meeting.

Over a few days, notice the list that forms. You may see that your actions already belong to the person you’re becoming, even if your self-image hasn’t yet caught up.

Reflection:

This week’s reflection is about that subtle lag between who you’ve become and who you still believe yourself to be. And sometimes it’s easier to see clearly when someone else helps hold the mirror. That’s the spirit behind my WhatsApp accountability coaching — short daily check-ins, no pressure, just presence.

If you’re curious, reply “accountability” and I’ll share how it works.

Curiosity Corner

Fresh Quote: “Becoming requires a willingness to be temporarily incoherent to yourself.” – Adam Phillips

Small Nugget: Identity lag is common in transitions — researchers note our brains cling to old labels for stability, even when our behaviors prove otherwise.

Book Reference: James Clear, Atomic Habits — identity-based habits aren’t about “what you do” but about “who you believe you are.”

​